# HB 459: Relating to the admissibility of a defendant's work of creative expression in a criminal trial.

90th Legislature (90R) · House · Status: Filed

Record current as of: the Legislative Council last updated this bill's record 11/11/2026 2:00:18 AM; this site copied it 2026-11-21T22:18:17.720605Z.

How to read this page: **Official record** is copied unchanged from the Texas Legislative Council's bill files, the data behind Texas Legislature Online. **Computed by this site** is worked out by fixed rules from that record. **AI analysis (Luna)** is written by an AI model that read the bill text; it can be wrong, so check it against the bill text.

## Official record

Source: Texas Legislative Council bill files (ftp.legis.state.tx.us), copied unchanged.

- Filed: 2026-11-09
- Most recent action: 2026-11-09 · House: Filed
- Official subjects (Legislative Council index): Arts & Humanities; Courts--Prosecuting Attorneys; Criminal Procedure--General
- Companion bills: none listed in the source data

### Caption

Relating to the admissibility of a defendant's work of creative expression in a criminal trial.

### Bill text

The official wording of each version, copied from the Texas Legislative Council's bill text files and converted to Markdown with the wording unchanged. Language the bill adds is marked <ins>like this</ins>; language it removes is in [<del>brackets</del>]. To check a copy, fetch the official file and compare its SHA-256 with the one listed; the copy's own SHA-256 confirms you received it unaltered.

- Introduced: https://billatlas.org/live/text/HB459/I.md
  - Official file: ftp://ftp.legis.state.tx.us/bills/90R/billtext/HTML/house_bills/HB00400_HB00499/HB00459I.HTM, last modified 2026-11-09 17:12:35 UTC, SHA-256 6bbe392e48f2030f62dfed1571ff40b5f36fda3b56141aa8e2d0e98bd4c589b3
  - This copy: made 2026-11-11T08:27:07.698538Z, SHA-256 of the Markdown 978a206b0d19d23e1873d1f991a9854d48dd8a0f4e44acc360181a8bc8d69ff6

#### Text of the latest version (Introduced)

````markdown
# HB 459 - Introduced

90R2593 AJZ-D

By: Bucy H.B. No. 459

A BILL TO BE ENTITLED

AN ACT

relating to the admissibility of a defendant's work of creative expression in a criminal trial.

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:

### SECTION 1.

Chapter 38, Code of Criminal Procedure, is amended by adding Article 38.52 to read as follows:

<ins>Art. 38.52. ADMISSIBILITY OF DEFENDANT'S WORK OF CREATIVE EXPRESSION. (a) In this article, "work of creative expression" means an expression or application of creativity or imagination in the production or arrangement of forms, sounds, words, movements, or symbols that is eligible for federal copyright protection under 17 U.S.C. Section 102. The term includes music, dance, performance art, visual art, poetry, literature, and film.</ins>

<ins>(b) A defendant's work of creative expression is not admissible against the defendant in a criminal trial, whether offered in the guilt or innocence phase or the punishment phase of the trial, unless:</ins>

<ins>(1) the attorney representing the state notifies the defendant of the state's intention to offer the work of creative expression as evidence in the trial; and</ins>

<ins>(2) in a hearing conducted outside the presence of the jury, the judge finds by a preponderance of the evidence that:</ins>

<ins>(A) the substance of the defendant's work of creative expression:</ins>

<ins>(i) was intended literally rather than figuratively or fictionally or, if the work is derivative, was intended as the defendant's own creative expression based on the literal part of the work;</ins>

<ins>(ii) was created near in time to or closely matches the facts of the alleged offense; and</ins>

<ins>(iii) relates to a disputed factual issue about the alleged offense or includes factual detail not otherwise publicly available; and</ins>

<ins>(B) the probative value of the defendant's work of creative expression substantially outweighs the danger of unfair prejudice.</ins>

### SECTION 2.

The change in law made by this Act applies to the admissibility of a work of creative expression in a criminal proceeding that commences on or after the effective date of this Act. The admissibility of a work of creative expression in a criminal proceeding that commences before the effective date of this Act is governed by the law in effect on the date the proceeding commenced, and the former law is continued in effect for that purpose.

### SECTION 3.

This Act takes effect September 1, 2027.
````

### Current law this bill changes

Each section as it stands now, from this site's copy of the Texas Legislative Council's statute files (wording unchanged); the official page is the authority. Sections are matched automatically from the bill text and can be missed, for example when a bill changes a whole chapter at once.

- Code of Criminal Procedure §38.52 (added (new section))
  - New section: no current text.

### Authors and sponsors

Authors and coauthors serve in the originating chamber; sponsors and cosponsors in the other chamber. Authorship does not indicate a vote or caucus position.

#### Authors

- John Bucy III (Democratic · HD 136 · 8 years served · since 2019) · [bills](https://agent.billatlas.org/authors/house-bucy.md)

_No coauthors, sponsors or cosponsors listed: no bill in this snapshot lists any yet, so this reflects the stage of the source data, not this bill._

### Recorded actions

1. 2026-11-09: Filed

## Computed by this site

Worked out by fixed rules from the official record above; not a statement by the Legislature.

- Status: Filed
- Most recent action type: Filed
- Hearing status: No hearing yet. No committee referral or hearing has been verified. A likelihood estimate would be premature.
- Authorship: Democratic author. Authors: 1 Democratic
- Author prominence: Mid-tenure author. 8 years in the House; 89R Elections vice chair (prior session, not confirmed for 90R)

## AI analysis (Luna)

Written by Luna, an AI model that reads the full bill text. It can be wrong; the bill text above is the authority. Tags marked caption-rules come from keyword rules applied to the caption, not from the AI.

### Summary

Reviewed 2026-11-14T01:08:33Z · introduced text. Fields from the full text: topics, agencies, impacts, constituencies, locations; other fields use caption inference.

HB 459 would make a defendant’s work of creative expression inadmissible against them in a criminal trial, whether in the guilt or innocence phase or the punishment phase, unless the state gives notice and a judge, at a hearing outside the jury’s presence, makes the required findings. Those findings include that the work’s probative value substantially outweighs the danger of unfair prejudice.

### Topics

- Criminal justice

### Potentially affected agencies

Possible links are rule or model inferences, not confirmed legal obligations.

_The full-text review tagged no state agency. This does not establish that none are affected._

### Types of impact

- Limits admission of creative expression as evidence

### People and institutions affected

- Criminal defendants whose creative expression is offered as evidence
- State prosecutors
- Judges in criminal trials

### Locations

- Statewide (statewide): The bill amends Texas criminal procedure and applies to qualifying criminal proceedings statewide.

## Links

- Full bill text (official wording, Markdown): https://billatlas.org/live/text/HB459/I.md
- Official bill history: https://capitol.texas.gov/BillLookup/History.aspx?LegSess=90R&Bill=HB459
- Official bill text (every version, HTML/PDF/Word): https://capitol.texas.gov/BillLookup/Text.aspx?LegSess=90R&Bill=HB459
- Open in the tracker: https://billatlas.org/bill/HB459
- RSS feed of actions: https://billatlas.org/live/feeds/HB459.xml
- This page as JSON: https://agent.billatlas.org/bills/HB459.json
- Search all bills: https://agent.billatlas.org/search?q= followed by your words, e.g. https://agent.billatlas.org/search?q=Criminal%20justice

---
Unofficial, independent open-source project; not a state website. The official record and bill text on this page are copied unchanged from the Texas Legislative Council bill files, refreshed hourly, so they can trail the Legislature by up to an hour or two. Computed fields and the AI analysis can be wrong. Not legal advice. For anything that matters, confirm on Texas Legislature Online.
